The Top Copycat Samoas, According to a Pro Baker

1 / 6

MOLLY ALLEN FOR TASTE OF HOME

How We Tested Copycat Samoas

To discover the finest Samoa cookies, we bought a box of initial Samoa Girl Scout Cookies along with 4 copycat variations. (We did a comparable test with the finest grocery shop cakes.)

The objective of this taste test was to discover something muchbetter or equivalent to the cherished Samoas that Girl Scouts sell. That implied finding a ring-shaped reward with a great crisp cookie (typically shortbread), a generous quantity of gooey caramel, flaked coconut and a touch of chocolate to round it all out.

2 / 6

Molly Allen for Taste of Home

Safeway Signature Select Caramel Coconut Fudge Cookies

This alternative can be discovered at Safeway shops or lotsof Albertsons shops. It looked quite similar to both the Benton’s cookies and the Crav’n cookies however didn’t taste or feel the exactsame. While the taste was good, this caramel coconut fudge dealwith didnothave balance. It had a really thick shortbread cookie in the center without sufficient caramel or fudge to balance it out.

Bottom line: While not bad, the ratio of cookie to caramel to fudge wasn’t enough to make this Samoa copycat stand out from the rest.

3 / 6

Molly Allen for Taste of Home

Keebler Coconut Dreams

We were shocked this alternative from Keebler didn’t rank greater. It did have a excellent quantity of fudge, both on the bottom and the leading, however more isn’t always muchbetter when it brings more sweettaste to the mix. There was less chocolate taste and less caramel. It had a dry, crispy cookie in the center, too—not at all like a genuine Samoa.

Bottom line: Overall, Keebler Coconut Dreams were OK. The great balance of chocolate, caramel and cookie simply wasn’t there.

4 / 6

Molly Allen for Taste of Home

Crav’n Caramel Coconut Fudgy Striped Cookies

Crav’n Caramel Coconut Fudgy Striped Cookies can be discovered at a number of sellers, consistingof Walmart. The cookies had a chewier shortbread center that wasn’t rather as thick, however there wasn’t much caramel. While this brandname does rank greater on the list for great taste, there were a coupleof textural qualities we discovered doingnothave when compared to the Girl Scout variation.

Bottom line: This is a good alternative if you’re yearning Samoas in the dead of fall and can’t wait till the next round of Girl Scout Cookies go on sale.

5 / 6