It’s a problem dealingwith more and more brandnames: Should your company sell on Amazon?
It’s the most checkedout e-commerce platform in the U.S. and the dominant seller in 28 other nations. But that reach comes at a cost. Harvard Business School partner teacher Ayelet Israeli states there are disadvantages for numerous Amazon sellers, like expenses, competitors, and the absence of information.
In this episode, Israeli provides a scorecard that can assistance you choose, action by action, whether or not the Amazon market is right for your company.
Key episode subjects consistof: method, development, management, scaling, Jeff Bezos, long-lasting believing, consumer focus.
HBR On Strategy curates the finest case researchstudies and discussions with the world’s top company and management professionals, to assistance you unlock brand-new methods of doing company. New episodes every week.
- Listen to the complete HBR IdeaCast episode: Why Companies Decide to Sell on Amazon—or Not (2022)
- Find more episodes of HBR IdeaCast
- Discover 100 years of Harvard Business Review shortarticles, case researchstudies, podcasts, and more at HBR.org
HANNAH BATES: Welcome to HBR On Strategy, case researchstudies and discussions with the world’s top company and management professionals — hand-selected to assistance you unlock brand-new methods of doing organization.
It’s a problem dealingwith more and more brandnames: oughtto you sell on Amazon? It’s the most checkedout e-commerce platform in the U.S. and the dominant merchant in 28 other nations.
But that reach comes at a cost. Harvard Business School partner teacher Ayelet Israeli states there are drawbacks for lotsof sellers – like expenses, competitors, and the absence of information.
In this episode, Israeli uses a “scorecard” that can assistance you choose, action by action, whether or not the Amazon market is right for your service.
This episode initially aired on HBR IdeaCast in August2022 Here it is.
CURT NICKISCH: Welcome to the HBR IdeaCast from Harvard Business Review. I’m Curt Nickisch.
It’s a problem dealingwith more and more brandnames nowadays. Should you sell your products on Amazon? At veryfirst look, the response has to be yes, ideal? Amazon is the most checkedout e-commerce platform in the United States. Two-thirds of U.S. clients start their item search on Amazon. Plus, it’s the dominant merchant in 28 other nations. And it grew so huge thanks to its satisfaction speed and quality of the purchasing experience. How can you state no to that that kind of reach?
Turns out, there are a lot of factors. There’s expenses. There’s more competitors, even from Amazon itself. And then there’s the information and feedback from consumers you offer up by not selling straight. What is a brandname to do? Our visitor today is here to aid services that are havingahardtime with that choice.
Ayelet Israeli is an partner teacher at Harvard Business School. Together with her HBS associates Leonard Schlesinger and Matt Higgins, as well as specialist Sabir Semerkant, she composed the HBR shortarticle “Should Your Company Sell on Amazon?”
Ayelet, how are you? Thanks for coming on the program.
AYELET ISRAELI: I’m fantastic. Thank you so much for having me.
CURT NICKISCH: Now, you compose in your post that, “Every brandname oughtto thinkabout offering on Amazon.” Why?
AYELET ISRAELI: In the years or so that I’ve been lookinginto retail, everybody discusses Amazon at some point. In the earlier days, business essentially had a yes or no, really clear cut technique. And nowadays, we hear more about what is your Amazon method rather than must you be on Amazon or not.
Amazon is simply so big. I believe the newest approximates I’ve seen is that approximately 40% of all online retail in the U.S. is on Amazon. So, it’s rather big. And then we’ve seen in current years likewise the boost in e-commerce in basic and how essential it is for brandnames to have their own online existence so that consumers can discover them, which makes Amazon an essential factortoconsider duetothefactthat you requirement to be someplace online, you requirement to serve your consumers. And Amazon does such a fantastic task in both having clients showup to the site, as well as providing them remarkable service. So, forthatreason every brandname oughtto, at the really least, thinkabout if they can be on Amazon or not.
CURT NICKISCH: This entire dispute advises me a lot of arguments in the past of huge box sellers like Walmart in the United States. Like if you were a customer items item, you essentially had to be there, ideal? But those extremely verysame business actually grumbled about simply how much the margins got squeezed. They actually regreted how tough they had to keep driving expenses down and not delightingin larger revenues duetothefactthat Walmart made them do it.
AYELET ISRAELI: Yeah, and it’s a really comparable story, the just distinction is simply the online existence. So, Walmart is of course, still a big merchant in the U.S., however their online existence out of overall U.S. e-commerce sales, Walmart is approximately 5% to 6%. So, they’re much smallersized than Amazon when you believe about online existence.
But they are still a huge gamer and brandnames still have the hasahardtime where they basically comprehend that in order to be where clients are looking for you, in the U.S., about 2 thirds of item searches start on Amazon rather than on search engines. So, that indicates most clients wear’t even go to Google or Bing or a search engine where they’re looking for something, they simply straight go to Amazon. And forthatreason, if you are not there and if you’re not a brandname that individuals absolutely desire to purchase, then you mostlikely are not going to be discovered by the bulk of clients.
CURT NICKISCH: But this likewise comes at a huge threat too, best? What are some of the leading line grievances about Amazon, if individuals utilized to grumble about margins getting squeezed at Walmart?
AYELET ISRAELI: Yeah. So, certainly margins getting squeezed is one of the huge ones, specifically these days when Amazon is doing a lot more in terms of marketing. I believe last year, their earnings from marketing were approximately $31 billion and they’re increasing those profits. They have a really big media platform. They can usage not simply the retail part of Amazon, however likewise Amazon Video or Amazon Music and other channels for their marketing. And so, not just you get squeezed on margins in the verysame conventional method like Walmart utilized to do it, however you likewise have extra expenses in terms of marketing. You desire to be included in the site in a popular location, you desire to be able to be the veryfirst brandname in the buy box where customers see you as the default brandname. And for all of these things, you basically have to offer up some of your margins.
CURT NICKISCH: Now, your post has a actually extensive scorecard that you can follow. If you’re a brandname, you can response concerns and rating whether you must be offering on Amazon or not. So, let’s go through the secret advantages of selling on Amazon and some of the factorstoconsider there.
AYELET ISRAELI: One of the things that we thinkabout other than margin, which we simply talked about is the item classification. Of course, there are some classifications that you merely cannot sell online.
CURT NICKISCH: Pretty easy response if you’re selling tobacco, ideal? Yeah.
AYELET ISRAELI: Yeah, precisely. There are likewise classifications that have suffered from what we call commoditization. Essentially, being on Amazon turned them, even if they weren’t thoughtabout by customers as products before, turned them into total products. Because you can see so numerous brandnames and even unidentified brandnames and sellers sell a variation of this item. They’re all side by side. They kind of appearance the exactsame. There is no huge differentiator. And then you’re generally cost shopping and thinkingabout that whatever is kind of the verysame, which turns every item into practically a product and not a brandname. And forthatreason, if you’re in a really commoditized market, it’s tough to stand out on a platform like Amazon’s.
CURT NICKISCH: Are batteries an example of this? Because you search AA, sort of a requirement battery in the United States there on Amazon and you get name brandnames, however you get a lot of rivals you wouldn’t even understand about. And you likewise have Amazon Basics brandname completing side by side.
AYELET ISRAELI: Yes. So, Amazon has rather a coupleof personal label brandnames. One of them is called Amazon Basics that you simply discussed, and batteries is a classification where Amazon Basics did extremely well and was able to get customers to buy their batteries. Their batteries are as excellent as others and customers simply purchased into it. Just a couple of weeks ago, Amazon revealed that they’re going to reevaluate their personal label technique. So, that may modification over time. But one thing that is interesting for me as somebody that scientists retail and particularly online retail is how things continuously modification. And it’s the verysame with Amazon.
CURT NICKISCH: Now, you’ve got to be looking at what you’re delivering, best? Because Amazon has, for numerous individuals, truly extraordinary shipping service and there are millions of Prime members. So, individuals who can order something and have the pledge of getting it provided for totallyfree with that subscription within a couple of days. But if you’re selling things that’s tough to ship, or if it’s strangely sized or requires modification, that endsupbeing more of a issue.
AYELET ISRAELI: Yeah, and that’s going to expense you a lot more. Now, of course, if you’ve neverever established a technique to ship your item and you just worked through suppliers, then maybe Amazon option might work for you if you haveactually offered online and another platform.
CURT NICKISCH: And why? Just because you’re utilized to paying someone to ship it for you basically?
AYELET ISRAELI: Yes.
CURT NICKISCH: Okay.
AYELET ISRAELI: Yes. So, there are distinctions. For example, if you’re selling ice cream or something that needs refrigeration, you usually work with circulation that has trucks that are freezers and things like that. And transforming that into selling online is a little bit moredifficult duetothefactthat now it’s not simply a big truck going to a physical shop or going from and to a storagefacility, however rather you requirement to ship to private customers, you requirement to have private services from them. Maybe they can’t choice it up right away when you provide it, so you requirement some kind of freezer. So, all of these are extra expenses that may be much more pricey than shipping through an developed conventional circulation system.
CURT NICKISCH: Yeah, duetothefactthat part of what makes Amazon so expense efficient is that they standardize a lot of that.
AYELET ISRAELI: . So, if you have a item that can be totally requirement and usage the requirement boxes, requirement shipping, you’ll have a much simpler time than with complex items. In a comparable way, items that are extremely individualized, you desire to match for every private customer are going to be harder on Amazon since they are, like you stated, they simply work with more requirement items with things that can fit mass market. You simply pick one, and that’s it.
CURT NICKISCH: This brandname concern is intriguing, ideal? Because you have to understand whether… I puton’t understand, it feels like you have to understand how distinguished your item is and how strong your brandname is before you sell on Amazon, since you have the danger of, if it’s not strong adequate or it doesn’t stand apart enough, you can actually waterdown your brandname.
AYELET ISRAELI: Absolutely. There is this intriguing dilemma here where if I’m a huge adequate brandname and that I have enough consumers that like me and will go to my site anyhow, then I puton’t requirement to be on Amazon since my clients will discover me and buy my item. At the verysame time, I’m a strong adequate brandname that can really makeitthrough on Amazon. So, I can do both things, best?
We have examples of really well understood brandnames that haveactually done well even being on Amazon. For example, Apple. We have other brandnames like Nike that haveactually piloted selling on Amazon and simply chose to gaveup the platform after a couple of years and rather establish and